Comments: On Socialism

Outstanding. I love the NN Taleb line "The free-market system lets you notice the flaws and hides its benefits. All other systems hide the flaws and show the benefits." That may not work on your VA friend, but that is a very good argument.

SIDE NOTE: I have lauded Taleb on these pages but he is persona non grata on my GMO sites for some anti-biotech nonsense. He is doubling down and it is war. To be fair, he is an odd bloke: he drinks nothing invented in the last 1000 years. Brilliant people can be wrong.

I find Internet memes so annoying that even ones I like are tainted, but there is a great one about that says "Socialism: so good people build rafts out of trash to escape it."

Posted by jk at August 17, 2015 10:20 AM

I'm giving Insty a twofer on the subject of Bernie Sanders and the socialism he espouses.

Insty links to a story at called that protrays the diference between socialism and the free market. Comrade Sanders is selling campaign tee-shirts. Union-made, et cetera. "Allow two to three weeks for delivery." He then demonstrates in the free-market environment of Amazon, hundreds of Comrade Sanders tee-shirts, in stock and primed for delivery in a day or two. Here's the link:

Comrade Sanders doesn't appreciate the value of competition. He famously whined that having 23 different deodorants and 18 choices of sneakers is a picture of what's wrong with America. He couldn't be more wrong; multiple competitors bringing their products to market, keeping the shelves stocked for immediately delivery and competing on price and quality, is exactly what distinguishes a free country from a failed Marxist state where the central planners force their subjects to stand in line at empty grocers, hoping that the officially-sanctioned bread baker will have products to sell sometime this week.

Posted by Keith Arnold at August 17, 2015 12:19 PM

Yes, that is an excellent and pithy defense of capitalism.

But what's wrong with government bakers? If it prevented the denial of a single gay wedding cake, wouldn't it be worth it?

Seriously though, a "government baker" WOULD be a "public place" because it is made possible by taxpayer dollars. Masterpiece Bakery is NOT a public place. It is a private place that offers its services to the public. Why are lawyers and judges so stupid? [/Trump voice]

Furthermore, same-sex plaintiff's attorney Ria Mar seems from his or her [apologies for the microagression ... "its?"] statements to support legal gay marriage. Why did the same-sex plaintiffs choose this attorney to represent them? Why didn't they force a "homophobic" Christian attorney to plead their case?

Posted by johngalt at August 17, 2015 2:53 PM

Yes, I feel a burning desire to adopt a child so that I can someday tell my grandchildren about the "cake police" of the early 21st Centiry.

Pardon me if you find the comparison trite, but where are you on the Woolworth's lunch counter? I cannot go full Goldwater and tell the private corporations that they can choose to not serve African Americans. I read many musical autobiographies and the hardships endured by black musicians in the American South is gut-wrenching.

I can differentiate between lodging and food as being required for life, but I confess that is opening a Carolene Footnote Four bifurcation.

Posted by jk at August 17, 2015 5:14 PM

I admit that this is easier for me to say than for someone who lived through it, but I would have preferred that government stay out of it. "Hardships" are unfortunate, but so is being forced to comply against one's will. The latter is even, I would argue, worse.

Government force distorts social structure just as it distorts economic markets. Our "reward" for government "fixing" racial divisions is Sandra Day O'Connor's majority opinion in Grutter v. Bollinger that "racial affirmative action wouldn't be constitutional permanently but long enough to correct past discrimination ─ an approximation limit of around 25 years, or until 2028."

A time limit on Constitutionality is pragmatism, not principle.

Posted by johngalt at August 18, 2015 12:22 PM
Post a comment

Remember personal info?