September 11, 2007Off-Grid LivingFor lunch in her modest apartment, Madeline Nelson tossed a salad made with shaved carrots and lettuce she dug out of a Whole Foods dumpster. She flavored the dressing with miso powder she found in a trash bag on a curb in Chinatown. She baked bread made with yeast plucked from the garbage of a Middle Eastern grocery store. In the country I grew up in, if Ms Nelson had kids, they would take away them away. Now she's celebrated. Freeganism was born out of environmental justice and anti-globalization movements dating to the 1980s. The concept was inspired in part by groups like "Food Not Bombs," an international organization that feeds the homeless with surplus food that's often donated by businesses. I work with a guy, still very liberal, who lived on a commune in the Seattle area in the seventies. They tried this. It's not new. I'm not quite sure why Marty left but "not really working out" seems to be a plausable reason. Read the whole, sad sad thing. From the other side Posted by AlexC at September 11, 2007 2:15 PM |
More transparency: this is what life is like if you "opt out of capitalism."
Posted by: jk at September 11, 2007 3:34 PM... by living off of it's refuse.
One of the quotes from captions... "She concedes that she was somewhat surprised once when she did not not get sick after eating salmon retrieved from a trash container."
Perhaps it's a miracle... a sign from Our Lady of Perpetual Squalor.
Posted by: AlexC at September 11, 2007 3:41 PMI had written a while back on starving Kenyans refusing food out of pride, and Freegans' misguided economics.
http://eidelblog.blogspot.com/2006/02/beggars-being-choosers.html
Putting aside the safety issues (never mind garbage cans, if something's left on the street corner, you can bet it's for a goddamn good reason!), for most of us, it's just not economically practical to search for hours to find scraps of food. It's better to spend those hours actually working, then go to the grocery store that helps minimize our search costs.
Posted by: Perry Eidelbus at September 12, 2007 10:22 AMI'll try and play JohnGalt here (he's probably on a cattle drive or something). It's a philosophy problem.
This is what happens when you give up your individual interests to pursue a nebulous public good. This woman has a college education and had a decent career. She allowed herself to believe that this is somehow better for the planet.
Where jg would likely not join me, is that I would point out that the world is really much better off having her work and create wealth and innovation. Let the professional trash removal crew do the job; they have a distinct comparative advantage.
Posted by: jk at September 12, 2007 10:38 AMI would join you in that assessment, JK: The "world" is much better off when every individual refuses to give up his individual interests.
I wasn't on a cattle drive yesterday. I was on sick leave. Damn salmon.
Posted by: johngalt at September 12, 2007 2:57 PMThe Salmon Moussssssse! Gets 'em everytime.
Posted by: jk at September 12, 2007 3:52 PM | What do you think? [6]